09-11-2008

Oxymoron of the day: Liberal strategy


Don Martin
Canwest News Service

Liberal leader Stephane Dion and his wife Janine Krieber board their election campaign plane Liberal leader Stephane Dion and his wife Janine Krieber board their election campaign plane. (Andy Clark/Reuters)

WALKERTON -There's a dizzy falling-down-the-rabbit-hole sensation to riding with Liberal leader Stephane Dion as his four-day-old tour finally defied gravity aboard a generation-old jet heading into Atlantic Canada.

It's almost as if the leader is a liability the campaign is trying to hide as the buses move from ridings that are impossible to win to safe seats where he makes announcements that simply don't make strategic sense.

His good days, er, hours have been limited to Conservative back-room hiccups that had nothing to do with invigorated Liberal ideas or his new macho image as a floor-hockey and fishing enthusiast. And that pooping puffin attack ad is now being seen as a one-time gift that risks becoming a memory-sticking defining Dion image.

The unveiling of the Liberals' meat safety policy in a Walkerton high school is a classic example of an outbreak of vertigo, which suggests the U2-borrowed campaign theme song of the same name is appropriate and shouldn't be scrubbed as planned.

It was a great crowd of 1,000, unfortunately non-voting teens, that was arguably larger than the combined turnout of Mr. Dion's entire rally and riding office pit stop tour so far.

But a teacher pulled me aside after Mr. Dion's talk to confide that Walkerton students are sick of being poster children for poison products in the aftermath of the killer E. coli contaminated water disaster of 2000.

That's why local reporters, who had been told Mr. Dion would limit his speech to his Green Shift carbon tax plan, winced when told it was a product safety announcement. Walkerton's water supply is a tragedy children and parents alike would rather forget and Mr. Dion's media parade merely refreshed the stigma for national consumption.

The infamous blue Walkerton water tower, visible from the school's front steps, might have been an appropriate photo-op backdrop, but I'm sure one student spoke for the many when all she wanted to know from Mr. Dion was how the Liberals would help a struggling single-parent family pay for her tuition next year.

Wait, the leader said, that announcement is scheduled for today in Saint John. Not in a high school? Huh? But that wasn't the only missed opportunity yesterday.

In what could've been a triumph of political brinkmanship over the bully antics of Prime Minister Stephen Harper, who had blocked Green Party leader Elizabeth May's obvious right to participate in the leaders' debate, Mr. Dion had meekly refused to boycott the event, even though he argued her vetoed participation was an affront to democracy.

Had he done so, Mr. Harper's capitulation yesterday could have framed Mr. Dion as a hero to women and advocate of free-speech. But without a defiant principled Liberal position, the flip-flop is merely a political bow to public pressure.

Speaking of women, yesterday also featured a round table to celebrate the Liberals' very strong team of articulate Toronto-area women, including two would-be leaders of the future. It was a golden opportunity to attack a Conservative Cabinet that marginalizes women and a party lineup lacking quality candidates.

But instead of attacking that record or listening to his candidates, Mr. Dion hogged the microphone to deliver a pandering talk on women in the home and raising children while insisting enforced gender parity should apply to the Senate, Crown corporations and throughout government. Yes, he deserves credit for delivering a key promise to have one-third of his national team be women.

Equal Voice, an action group dedicated to electing more women, notes approvingly that 36% of the Liberal candidates are women, 26% of them in ridings considered winnable in this election.

But behind every defeated female candidate will be a failed national leader, so Mr. Dion had best pull up his campaign socks and get people excited about his mission or his candidate quota won't matter one iota.

Trouble is obviously afoot on other fronts. In the Greater Toronto Area fortress for the Liberal party, a major rally that MPs were told would happen this week was inexplicably scrubbed. Thus, Mr. Dion left the city without a sendoff hug from his star candidates.

Behind the scenes, sources say the Liberal party will quietly cancel its December convention in Vancouver, clearing the decks for a leadership convention next year if this tour continues evolving into a funeral procession. The Liberal leader's strategy so far is the classic sign of a party coasting on a lead.

Someone should let Mr. Dion know that some polls have him a distant second place to the Conservatives and flirting dangerously close to New Democrat Jack Layton for the right to be runner-up. The Liberal right-to-life campaign to make this election relevant had better start soon.

Super Albertan says:

Firstly, Canadians were tired of the polished political personalities who had their hair spray on so tight that the entire process of thinking was hindered! We all wanted someone we could relate to, someone who was not a career politician or a lawyer! Stephen Dion only came into politics to ensure that our country remained united at the request of Paul Martin.

Don Martin has removed himself from Alberta but his Alberta Tory prejudice is shining bright - let's be objective shall we - The fact remains that while the airplane may be old - does anyone really think that the Liberals specifically asked for the oldest plane in the fleet?

Stephen Dion is a Canadian who has put himself in harms way here at home in order that the country will survive. As a University Professor he could have stayed out of the political arena, he could have remained in a classroom but he was asked to leave all of that behind and help defend our country, he was asked to run for leader of the party at a time when being a Liberal in Quebec was like being associated with Criminals! Every party has their own criminals but it now appears that the CONservatives will take the lead - but we will have to wait for that decision unless the Tories get a majority in which case we will never know who is the Liar, Brian Mulroney or Karl Heinz Scheiber! This election call has left a Parliamentary inquiry in the dark - and who gains from our lack of knowledge on the Mulroney/ Schieber affair? Stephen Harper does - no one else!

Come on Don Martin if you have follow Stephen Dion arround the country try to be polite and show some respect for a Canadian who stepped up to the plate at the worst moment many Liberals have experienced. He may not have the charisma of a sex symbol but neither does Stephen Harper. Mr. Dion does have a better team in place though who can lead this country even from a thirty-year old airplane. Its about principle Don, and Mr. Harpers principles are the ones we need to question as a nation - he needs to defend his actions not Mr. Dion. Let's face it while Mr. Dion was defending our country from separation, Stephen Harper was writing letters to build "walls" around Alberta.

I think it would have been a better assignment for you if you had covered Harper instead of Mr. Dion.

Super Albertan

Don says:

Mr. Martin - with the grinding tour of whistle stops that any candidate has to make, it is impossible to address every issue that may arise during each stop. There is barely enough time to speak about the topics selected for a given area, let alone spontaneous ones. Mr. Dion has to depend on party members to prompt him on key speaking issues for each location, then its off to the next stop. Imagine all those frequent flyer miles for each candidate!

Super Albertan - I am pleasantly surprised and grateful that not all Albertans are pro Conservative. Your points are well taken. But like it or not (and I don't), a party has to have a strong leader. Mr. Harper has had more experience at this, being on the world stage and interacting with its leaders. So he comes from a position of strength compared to Mr. Dion. The latter exhibits more human traits than our PM and for that I agree with your comments - that he is making the best go of a difficult situation. It is chilling to watch Harper morph from an icy individual into a suddenly warm and caring one. Post election, it will be back to the freezer.

Don Martin is unabashedly pro Conservative, choosing to conveniently forget the many examples of poor leadership and performance so early into this election. As to principles, Harper has tried to sweep the Mulroney scandal under the rug. Imagine if you will envelopes of HUGE amounts of cash behind closed doors, all done very secretively. With a voluntary disclosure to the tax authorities to avoid being charged criminally. That's one public case that should proceed. If Harper gets a majority, he had better not dismiss any further actions. It was he (and Mulroney - false bravado) who initiated the inquiry so he'd best see it to completion or its his principles that will be right out the door.

Danny Williams has the right idea. Let's ABC Harper into a minority.

Code of Conduct

Thank you for visiting our site. Here are some guidelines for posting comments to our blogs and articles. Should you have any questions, please contact us.

You may not post anything that:

  • Infringes or violates any copyright, trademark, service mark, patent, trade secret, confidentiality rights or other rights of any third party;
  • Is abusive, harmful, tortuous, or is racially, ethnically or otherwise objectionable;
  • Is libelous, defamatory or invades any privacy or publicity rights of any third party;
  • Contains or promotes criminal activity;

Some things to keep in mind when posting:

  • Respect: respect the guidelines and Terms of Use for the site’s usage. Respect Global News, its employees, and fellow community members.
  • Personal attacks and flames will not be tolerated. Constructive criticisms are acceptable; however, general attacks on a person will not be tolerated.
  • Commercial postings/solicitations are not allowed. Commercial content as a direct or indirect attempt to solicit customers through a post will be removed.
  • If someone has posted copyrighted material or otherwise illegal material, please notify Global News so that it may be removed.

We moderate all comments, blogs and forums and reserve the right to pull any inappropriate submissions from the site at our discretion.

We advise that you review the site’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy and by visiting the site and using its services you are agreeing to the sites User Agreements and Privacy Policy.

Key Candidates


Previous
Stephen Harper

Stephen Harper

Conservative Party

Stéphane Dion

Stéphane Dion

Liberal Party

Gilles Duceppe

Gilles Duceppe

Bloc Québécois

Jack Layton

Jack Layton

New Democratic Party

Elizabeth May

Elizabeth May

Green Party

Olivia Chow

Olivia Chow

New Democratic Party

Michael Ignatieff

Michael Ignatieff

Liberal Party

Mike Nagy

Mike Nagy

Green Party

Justin Trudeau

Justin Trudeau

Liberal Party

Peter MacKay

Peter MacKay

Conservative Party

Jim Flaherty

Jim Flaherty

Conservative Party

Michael Fortier

Michael Fortier

Conservative Party

Bob Rae

Bob Rae

Liberal Party

Martha Hall Findlay

Martha Hall Findlay

Liberal Party

Thomas Mulcair

Thomas Mulcair

New Democratic Party

Peter Van Loan

Peter Van Loan

Conservative Party

Marc Garneau

Marc Garneau

Liberal Party

John Baird

John Baird

Conservative Party

Stockwell Day

Stockwell Day

Conservative Party

 
Next